Is this a serious request? Most people who state unequivocally their ideological stance arenтАЩt interested in the practical. It amazes me that you and others make the argument that AI use is harmful to creativity and intellectual pursuits zero evidence. Why should I expect you to be interested in evidence at all? ThatтАЩs why I refer to the bottle of water argument as sound and fury, completely irrelevant to the argument around AI in public school classrooms. IтАЩm in the middle of writing a textbook for high school writing teachers about teaching Ai theory in composition. It will likely be available in the fall of next year. IтАЩll send you the link.
Yes, I was serious. Why shouldnтАЩt I? ItтАЩs just that I havenтАЩt made up my mind yet. Why do you think I am stating ai is harmful per se? I am just starting on this journey, I donтАЩt think I have any preconceived notions - at least I hope so. So I donтАЩt understand why I offended you asking for references?
IтАЩm a researcher in language and literacy with three decades of experience. Asking me for a url to prove that AI can help kids is demeaning. I suggested that you check it out because it would take some effort on your part. I could send you 10 URLs. What do you know about passive vs active vocabulary development? Findings from a study mean little unless you understand the conceptual framework, the variables. Tell you what. This was your question which led me to believe your mind is already made up: тАЬcan ai really assist in creative writing and deep thinking or is the net result always negative in this regard?тАЭ The tells are тАЬreally assistтАЭ and тАЬalways negative.тАЭ The тАЬreallyтАЭ implies doubt, the тАЬalwaysтАЭ implies certainty. ThatтАЩs the only way I can make sense of your question. The answer is тАЬyesтАЭ it can really help kids learn. Khanmigo has evidence up the wazoo. It gets frustrating seeing these bottle of water comments and fears that it doesnтАЩt really help and it could be alway negative. You should read the post I just uploaded about the milque toast advice from the APA Stlye committee on citations and AI. They are not taking it seriously
Yes, AI can help kids, Maurice. Check out the emerging evidence. The principled stuff is sound and fury.
Any reference (links) at hand here, Terry?
Is this a serious request? Most people who state unequivocally their ideological stance arenтАЩt interested in the practical. It amazes me that you and others make the argument that AI use is harmful to creativity and intellectual pursuits zero evidence. Why should I expect you to be interested in evidence at all? ThatтАЩs why I refer to the bottle of water argument as sound and fury, completely irrelevant to the argument around AI in public school classrooms. IтАЩm in the middle of writing a textbook for high school writing teachers about teaching Ai theory in composition. It will likely be available in the fall of next year. IтАЩll send you the link.
Yes, I was serious. Why shouldnтАЩt I? ItтАЩs just that I havenтАЩt made up my mind yet. Why do you think I am stating ai is harmful per se? I am just starting on this journey, I donтАЩt think I have any preconceived notions - at least I hope so. So I donтАЩt understand why I offended you asking for references?
IтАЩm a researcher in language and literacy with three decades of experience. Asking me for a url to prove that AI can help kids is demeaning. I suggested that you check it out because it would take some effort on your part. I could send you 10 URLs. What do you know about passive vs active vocabulary development? Findings from a study mean little unless you understand the conceptual framework, the variables. Tell you what. This was your question which led me to believe your mind is already made up: тАЬcan ai really assist in creative writing and deep thinking or is the net result always negative in this regard?тАЭ The tells are тАЬreally assistтАЭ and тАЬalways negative.тАЭ The тАЬreallyтАЭ implies doubt, the тАЬalwaysтАЭ implies certainty. ThatтАЩs the only way I can make sense of your question. The answer is тАЬyesтАЭ it can really help kids learn. Khanmigo has evidence up the wazoo. It gets frustrating seeing these bottle of water comments and fears that it doesnтАЩt really help and it could be alway negative. You should read the post I just uploaded about the milque toast advice from the APA Stlye committee on citations and AI. They are not taking it seriously
I can see how that quick reply came across. Again: not meant to be disrespectful.